I've had an account at Ancestry.com for years. I have also had a tree on FamilySearch. But I recently got curious about WikiTree and decided to poke about in it.
Yeah, that poking about got me hooked.
I find a lot to like about Ancestry.com. My tree there is MY tree there. I decide what gets posted to it. I demand and exercise the use of reliable sources. I've had a good deal of training in genealogy, a lot of it emphasizing the need for good source citations. I don't have to worry about someone lacking any training in genealogy putting misinformation on my Ancestry tree.
I love FamilySearch for its documents and records and its research information and instructive articles. I don't love constantly having to correct misinformation, usually unsourced, again and again and again, concerning my ancestors. So I will use the immense number and variety of original and derivative sources on FamilySearch. I will take advantage of their marvelous research guides and their wonderful wiki. But I'm not wasting my time anymore on that tree.
Enter WikiTree. It is also a collaborative tree. However, it is a lot more likely to be accurate. For one thing, to use WikiTree, one must sign their Honor Pledge, which states that we will back up every fact with a reliable source or sources. For another, WikiTree is mainly by genealogists for genealogists, people who have had some training in the field and who understand its requirements. And finally, the idea behind WikiTree is that we all help grow the best, most reliable, and most accurate tree we can make, so people in the future have a highly useful body of information about their ancestors there on the Web.
I've wondered how I was going to preserve and pass on my family history. My daughters and grandson don't have the passion, though my grandson does enjoy hearing family stories. But they have other concerns taking their attention. I do plan to leave a lot of documents and research to a genealogy society or societies. WikiTree now also figures into my plan of how to preserve and pass on my family history.
WikiTree also has a great deal of mentoring. One of these mentorships is their Profile Improvement Project (PIP). The profile is the individual entry of information (well-sourced, of course) about an ancestor. A good profile has as much information as one can gather, representing a "reasonably exhaustive" body of research, and analysis of what it all means. To show you the results my participation in the Profile Improvement Project has rendered, you are invited to see my profile of my granduncle and adoptive grandfather, Perry W. Reed. WikiTree has a hugely long learning curve, and the PIP helps a lot in getting through it.
Another handy learning tool is their G2G (Genealogist to Genealogist) communication facility. There, a user can ask questions about genealogy, about the technology of WikiTree, and about WikiTree's policies. The policies are set by various functions in WikiTree, and those functions are staffed by members of WikiTree. WikiTree is very FUBU (For Us, By Us).
No comments:
Post a Comment